In Part 1 of this series, we asked the question: How do Christians, the new covenant people of God, obey the Sabbath command today? We answered that question by pointing to the glorious reality that Jesus fulfills the Sabbath. Indeed, the old covenant sign and command of the Sabbath actually pointed to Jesus and the greater rest he would offer all along. The old covenant Sabbath command was but a shadow, Jesus is the substance (Colossians 2:16–17). In short, Jesus is our Sabbath rest. Therefore, we fulfill the heart of the old covenant Sabbath command by entering into and embracing the salvation we have through him. Ultimately, belief in Christ and our union with Christ is what it looks like to enter into God’s rest exemplified in Gen 2:2–3. So if we ‘obey’ the Sabbath command by believing in Jesus, what then do we do with the Sabbath Day?

Two specific questions generally come up when we think about how Christians relate to the Sabbath Day: (1) Is Sunday the new Sabbath Day for Christians? and (2) How should Christians practice Sabbath wisdom today? In this article, I will address the first question. In a forthcoming article, we will look at how Christians should practice Sabbath wisdom today. But before seeking to answer either of these questions, I think it benefits us to refresh ourselves on how to approach matters of Christian conscience.

A Word Regarding Conscience

It is helpful to acknowledge at the outset that the Sabbath Day question can be a tricky and touchy one. Indeed, faithful Christians who joyfully walk hand-in-hand on a number of different theological points might find themselves staring at each other across the proverbial fence when it comes to the question of the Sabbath Day. But disagreement regarding what the Sabbath Day looks like for the Christian does not mean that happy unity need be torn asunder! Rather, Christians recognize that their common salvation hinges on Christ alone. This is what unifies them. Therefore, the guiding principle for Christians of different stripes on this matter is this: Seek to honor the Lord. Then, let that desire to honor the Lord inform conscience with regard to implementing Sabbath wisdom. And, finally, refrain from seeking to force others to adopt specific practices that might be against their conscience. Do this for the sake of Christian unity and Christian freedom. Paul addresses such issues of conscience in Romans.

Romans 14:5–6 — One person esteems one day as better than another, while another esteems all days alike. Each one should be fully convinced in his own mind. The one who observes the day, observes it in honor of the Lord.

Even given that new covenant believers perpetually abide in Sabbath rest in Christ, there emerges an apparent issue among the Roman Christians. In light of this new covenant reality, some Christians, still approach certain days with unique regard. This could very likely refer to Sabbath practices perhaps held by some Jewish Christians in the Roman church. Others, though, consider all of equal significance. Piper makes the important clarifying point here that this considering “all days alike” does not necessarily mean that they are all considered common. Rather, what is most likely meant, given the new age of Sabbath rest in Christ, is that all days are considered alike in that they are all holy. The new covenant age brings escalation. Every day is holy. So each side would recognize every day as holy, but they took different approaches as to how they regarded those holy days.

Interestingly, Paul does not take sides in the debate. Rather, Paul recognizes varying degrees of faith regarding less clearly defined issues (Romans 14:1). He then points out what is really at stake in such cases: the conscience of the believer and the Lord’s due honor. Paul says, “Each one should be fully convinced in his own mind” (Romans 14:5). Resolved in conscience, one should then do what they do for the purpose of honoring the Lord (Romans 14:6). Indeed, seeking to honor the Lord should inform consciences on such matters like the Sabbath. For, according to Paul, Christians are ultimately all in the same boat. “For we will all stand before the judgment seat of God” (Romans 14:10). All will stand before the Lord to give account for their thoughts and actions. Therefore, Paul asks the piercing question, “Why do you pass judgment on your brother? Or you, why do you despise your brother” (Romans 14:10). Even in light of this disagreement, Paul reminds his readers of their unity in Christ. They are brothers still. Their common foundation is the gospel of Jesus. Matters of conscience like this should not lead to disunity. Rather, we should each encourage one another to seek to honor God.

So, disagreements of conscience on non-foundational gospel issues do not need to lead to discord or the hurling of stones. This in mind, let us consider what the Sabbath Day looks like for Christians.

Is Sunday the New Sabbath Day for Christians?

Is the Sunday the Sabbath Day for Christians? Not necessarily. The Sabbath Day was the seventh day, Saturday, under the old covenant. And, there is no explicit command in the New Testament for Christians to keep the old covenant Sabbath Day or to consider Sunday the new Sabbath. I say not necessarily, though, because in another sense Sunday could be understood as the Sabbath in the same way that Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, and Saturday could all be understood as the Sabbath. You see, for the Christian, every day is the Sabbath because we rest in Christ. Hubbard captures this idea well in his article on Desiring God, saying pithily, “Faith in Jesus Christ brings the rest of the seventh day into every day.”[1] So Sunday is not the Sabbath Day for Christians in the old covenant command sense. Scripture (and Church history) reveals that Sunday is something else.

The first day, Sunday, is the normative day for gathering of the local church for corporate worship. This pattern of gathering together for worship on the first day emerges in Scripture (Acts 20:7; 1 Corinthians 16:2). It’s commonly accepted that John identifies what the first Christians referred to this day as when he writes, “I was in the Spirit on the Lord’s day” (Revelation 1:10). Why did John refer to it as the Lord’s Day? Because Sunday was the day Christ rose from the tomb! (Luke 24:1). It is into this context of corporate worship on the Lord’s Day that the author of Hebrews issues this command: “And let us consider how to stir up one another to love and good works, not neglecting to meet together as is the habit of some” (Hebrews 10:24–25). Thus, this passage shouldn’t be misconstrued as merely two Christians getting together for coffee. Rather, the established pattern of formal fellowship on the Lord’s Day in Scripture implies a normative practice. Christians should gather together for corporate worship, and, in normative circumstances, they do this on the Lord’s Day. Church history affirms this.

Bauckham observes, “we have seen reasons for holding that Sunday worship began at an early stage of Christian history and was from an early stage understood as commemorative of the Lord’s resurrection on the first day of the week.”[2] The Lord’s Day, then, is inherently different from the old covenant Sabbath command. Baukham goes on to observe, “for the earliest Christians it [the Lord’s Day] was not a substitute for the Sabbath nor a day of rest nor related in any way to the fourth commandment.”[3] In fact, for many early Christians, Sunday was a typical day of work. Therefore, they would worship early before going to work and then perhaps gather again in the evening after work. The Lord’s Day is a day of corporate worship rooted in the new covenant work of Jesus and the new age of salvation he secured by his resurrection.

So Scripture and history do not suggest that Christians must adopt an old covenant Sabbath approach to the Lord’s Day. Rather, Sunday, the Lord’s Day, is the normative corporate day of worship for Christians. And the Bible makes clear that Christians should not neglect gathering together in such corporate ways. And, as far as possible given varying contexts that Christians find themselves in, gathering on the Lord’s Day would follow the pattern of Scripture and Church History. In light of these things, consider this amazing reality. From the time of Christ’s resurrection and up through the centuries to today Christians throughout the world have gathered together and continue to gather together to open the Word, pray, herald the gospel, sing praises, break bread, pass the cup, and baptize new believers on the Lord’s Day, Sunday. In short, Christians gather together to worship the Triune God for the salvation, the new creation—the true Sabbath rest!—that he inaugurated and secured through the risen king, Jesus.[4] What a privilege it is to be a part of this great fellowship of the saints. And, what a privilege and joy it is to look forward to gathering with you, DGCC, on Sunday, the Lord’s Day.

In light of this, there still remains much wisdom to draw from the Sabbath pattern established by God at creation. In a forthcoming article, I will explore answers to our second question: How should Christians practice Sabbath wisdom today?

[1] Scott Hubbard, “Should Christians Keep the Sabbath?,” Desiring God, 20 April 2021, https://www.desiringgod.org/articles/should-christians-keep-the-sabbath.

[2] R.J. Baukham, “The Lord’s Day,” in From Sabbath to Lord’s Day: A Biblical, Historical and Theological Investigation, ed. D. A. Carson (Eugene, OR: Wipf and Stock Publishers, 1999), 240.

[3] Baukham, “The Lord’s Day,” 240.

[4] For a very helpful biblical, historical, and theological deep dive into the relationship of the Sabbath Day and the Lord’s Day, look to D.A. Carson’s From Sabbath to the Lord’s Day.